S’mores cookie cups – they’re pretty much one of the best cookies ever, they taste like campfire s’mores only better and in cookie form and were part of our annual cookie and cocktail exchange party we had this past weekend.
Every year we have a cookie and cocktail exchange party. People who want to enter the exchange can do so and leave with a bag full of cookies, and then also have their cookies entered into the voting. There’s a category for best tasting, best looking, and most Christmas themed.
In addition to the cookies portion we also do a cocktail exchange. People can bring a cocktail and then serve the cocktail in little glasses and then they make a display one. The display ones are entered into the cocktail voting – best tasting, best looking and most Christmas themed. There are voting cards (here are the ones I made which we used) and there are PRIZES!
This is the 4th year we’ve had the party, the whole thing is pretty neat if I do say so myself. Friends and family from all different walks of life gather to celebrate the holidays, our house is small but it’s cozy. Last year my husband came up with the idea for the dark and stormy oatmeal cream pie cookies and this year when we were talking about what cookies to make he came up with the idea for these s’mores cookie cups (I think he just wanted to use a torch haha).
These cookies have a graham cracker-sugar cookie crust, a chocolate ganache filling with a hint of bourbon and are topped with marshmallow creme which is brûléed with a torch. I made the cookie layer in little paper cups (clean up in the pan is easier this way) but when brûléing the marshmallow creme some of the edges caught fire a little, so just a note of caution that that is completely fine and normal. In fact, here’s a little video of us using the torch (we bought this one and it was absolutely fantastic!)
Remove the paper cups before serving. They were delicious – have you ever been to a cookie or cocktail exchange? I’d love to know!
S'mores Cookie Cups
Ingredients
Instructions
Here are some photos from the party:
Sign up for email updates and get a free eCookbook with our top 25 recipes!
Megan - The Emotional Baker says
What a fun exchange! I would probably try to take as many of these as I could 😉 I mean who couldn’t love Smores in cookie cup form?
Sweetphi says
Hahahaha, I hear you on taking these, I think I was a little sad when my hubby ate the last one, but hey…that just means we have to make another batch, right? Thank you so much for your comment 🙂
Dannii @ Hungry Healthy Happy says
This looks like so much fun! Can you believe that I have never had smores before? I seriously think that I am missing out.
Sweetphi says
You’ve never had s’mores before?!? That totally needs to change, these cookies are perfect for that 😉
cheri says
Hi Phi, what a great party to have every year, sounds like so much fun, love the smore cookies so clever.
Sweetphi says
Thank you so much Cheri, the party is so much fun every year, and these s’mores cookies were absolutely perfect for the party 🙂
Trisha says
I had so much fun hosting my first ever cookie-exchange this year. Bookmarking this recipe for next year! I don’t have a kitchen torch but the idea of using one sounds really fun…..:) Would love to see more photos of your cookie and cocktail exchange!
Sweetphi says
Thank you so much Trisha. My hubby actually bought the torch specifically for these cookies…I can’t wait to use them with other desserts. I’ll definitely be sharing more photos in a post next year, I just always forget to take more pictures as the party is going on, you know? Yay for holidays and cookies 🙂
Little Cooking Tips says
What a wonderful party idea! These cupcakes look delicious, and since they include chocolate ganache, Panos has already bookmarked the recipe:)
Thank you for another yummy idea dear Phi!
xoxo
Sweetphi says
Do you have cookie parties in Greece? I know they’re pretty popular here in the US, so I was curious 🙂 My husband had so much fun using the little kitchen torch-such a fun piece of equipment!
Little Cooking Tips says
We don’t have cookie parties here, but showing up with some dessert when you visit someone is a die hard custom we have here:) Most people buy them from pastry shops nowadays though, while in the past they were homemade. Thank you for asking for our culture:)
xoxoxo