I tried 6 home meal delivery services…here is my comparison

Lately I feel like there have been an abundance of commercials for home meal delivery services. Services that deliver a box of fresh, pre-portioned food and recipes right to your doorstep. I wanted to try them out, so…I tried 6 home meal delivery services, and I’m sharing what I thought and a comparison of the different services. Since posting this meal delivery services comparison review, I’ve added several services I tried and loved, I think up to date I’ve tried 10 services. I’ll keep updating this article as I try more.

With life being so busy – between work, being a new mom and just life in general, I was starting to really feel like I was in a cooking rut. I didn’t even want to think about what to make for dinner, I had zero inspiration, zero time to go to the grocery store, and zero motivation. When I kept hearing all the commercials for meal delivery services, I thought I’d look into them and give them a try. There are so many different companies out there! I made a list of all the different ones I wanted to try out, and each week tried a different service.

Here are some of the pros and cons, and at the bottom of the post I share a comparison chart to give an overview.

Sun Basket

I was a little late to the game trying Sun Basket, but they have easily become my favorite (I should have listened to friends who had tried it sooner!) If you want to read a review of the best healthy meal delivery service I wrote about them, click here.

Pros:

• Healthy meals (that don’t taste ‘healthy’). I like that I don’t have to look at the calories per meal, because they’re generally all under 600-700 calories per meals (other meal delivery services per serving sometimes are 1200+ calories!)
• Lots of options
• They let you preview the meals before you become a member
• Lots of options for different diet-friendly meals (like vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, etc.)
• Organic ingredients
• They include eggs! A lot of meal delivery services don’t include eggs for recipes that call for eggs, so I was very pleasantly surprised that they did. 
• Their weekly box comes with a magazine which includes the recipes and also other helpful articles and recipes, it read like a magazine!

Cons: 

• The meals are very healthy and delicious, but if you’re looking for something a little more on the indulgent side, this service is probably not for you. They have a lot of unique healthy recipes, so you don’t miss any of the unhealthy stuff. But if you’re a ‘steak & potatoes’ type of person, I’d try one of the other services.
• The magazine (which was listed in the pro section) is nice, but it’s a little hard to find the recipes that are in your meal kit – I wish they would list the page numbers on the ingredients to make it easier to put the ingredients together with the recipe.

Home Chef

Pros:

• Loved that there were lots of meals to choose from
• Lots of delivery day options which is always nice
• Absolutely LOVE that besides the designated meal plans you can add additional meals (so if the plan is 3 meals for a family of 4, if that week you want 4 or 5 of the meals, you can add them on and not change your plan!)
• One can add on breakfast/fruit/smoothie/premium meals which is nice
• Food is really tasty – their flatbreads or meatball options, whenever I see them on the menu I order them because they’re so good. Honestly, their food tastes SO GOOD!
• A binder came with the first order so that one could put all the recipes in the binder
• Definitely most flexibility if you’re a family of 2, 4 or 6 or if there are vegetarians, you don’t have to completely change plans, you can choose vegetarian options. This is great for families
• All the ingredients for a recipe were in a bag
• The food is so good, I got my sister hooked on this service after she tried two other services. They have the most ‘family-friendly’ meals too (meaning menu items that I think the whole family would enjoy!)
• I wrote another post about Home Chef and meal delivery for special occasions (like for example for Valentines Day!)

Cons:

• Their website was a little difficult to figure out at first (I had to email them to ask about how to ‘skip/pause’ weeks)

Plated

Pros:

• Loved the flexibility of the plans (you can chose 2-7 meals per person per week)
• The food was by really really good, I literally kept two of the recipe cards to make again and there were SO MANY TASTY options!
• If you’re an adventurous eater, this is the plan for you!
• You can add on dessert, I did and we loved it
• All the ingredients for one recipe were in one bag which was really nice
• Loved that they sent aluminum/throw away pans for items needing to be baked
• I used ingredients I never would have tried, really unique menu items

Cons

• Didn’t like that you had to use your own eggs (example, if a recipe called for eggs or oil, they do not provide it. Oil is understandable, but I thought they should not assume I have eggs on hand).
• Some of the flavor combinations/meal options are a little out there. My sister tried this one and ended up switching to Home Chef because her husband just did not like the menu options.

I wrote a post on a Plated review if you’re interested in that.

Martha & Marley Spoon

I  tried Martha & Marley Spoon after writing this review but had to add it in. It is Martha Stewart’s meal delivery program. The food is good, very family friendly. I liked that some of the recipes are from Martha’s cookbooks.

Pros: 

• Very family friendly.
• Love that some of the recipes are from Martha’s cookbooks, and that there are adaptations and time saving tricks. For example if a recipe is made in a pressure cooker/Instant Pot, it will give directions for the pressure cooker and how to make it if you don’t have one.
• The food is super good, recipes the whole family would love. I’ve kept several of the recipes to make again.
• There are plenty of options.
• I felt like the portions were perfect.

Cons:

• I did feel like some of the recipes used a lot of dishes to make them, but I’ve come to find that a lot of meal delivery kits recipes do use quite a few dishes and kitchen utensils.

Terra’s Kitchen

Pros:

• The shipping vessel this comes in is the coolest thing ever, my husband loved that they come and pick up the vessel/box so that it is very recycling friendly and there’s no empty boxes/trash to deal with
• The organization of the ingredients is amazing
• Ingredients have expiration dates on them which I really liked
• One can choose from 30 different recipes, all with varying prices
• One can add salads/smoothies/proteins/pastas and snacks
• Meals were very delicious
• Loved the minimal prep- everything was chopped/ready to go

Cons

• A little on the pricey side with meals varying from $10.99 per person per meal to $18.99
• I wish they’d change the recipes/meal options more often
• Sometimes some of the pre-cut veggies go bad sooner than I’ve been able to use them

Green Chef

Pros:

• All organic (the other organic meal service I LOVE is Sun Basket, I’ve gotten so many comments about them and they’re allergy/diet friendly!)
• Meals came with sauces that were already made and were really tasty
• Minimal prep, only had to chop 1 or 2 things per recipe
• Loved the way the food/recipe cards were labeled and color coded, it made it very easy to know which items to use
• Meals were done (start to finish including prep) in 30 minutes

Cons:

• Didn’t like that one couldn’t swap out meals/recipes. You choose a plan and then are just sent the designated meals
• Online system doesn’t show more than two weeks in advance upcoming meals
• This could be a pro or con – the portion sizes were huge. Each meal for 2 we ended up having leftovers for a 3rd meal.
• We waited 4 days to make one of the recipes – veggie burgers- the arugula and kale were rotten. Contacted customer service and they immediately apologized and gave a credit on our account.

Blue Apron

Pros:

• The food tasted really good
• Appropriate serving sizes, no extra portions
• Liked that one could choose between a few meals

Cons:

• Lots of chopping/prep work
• Lots of dishes/utensils required
• Lots of making sauces/different components of the dish
• Missing key ingredients (emailed their customer service and they immediately apologized and gave me a credit on our account.)
• Cooking instructions/times were wrong on 2 of the 3 recipes (example 6 minutes to cook an entire chicken breast – it was still raw on the inside)
• Cooking times varied and the dishes took a lot longer than expected to make, one 30 minute expected time ended up taking close to 50 minutes from start to finish.
• A lot of leftover ingredients (example: sent whole head of garlic when all one needs is 1 clove)

Hello Fresh

Pros:

• Really liked that all the ingredients for a particular recipe came in a box with all the ingredients for that recipe
• Unique flavor combinations
• One can choose different meal options, but there’s not a lot of flexibility between plans (if you want a family plan, there are only a few options, same with the vegetarian plan, there are only three options, and one can’t get a vegetarian meal with other meat meals)
• Liked that the meal options include a breakfast one
• All the food was tasty
• Easy directions to follow

Cons:

• The website is as not as easy to use as other ones, but once one knows where everything is it gets easier
• There are not a lot of options on some of the plans (for example, if you want a family plan and have 3 meals, there’s only 5 to choose from) versus if you’re on a 2 person plan, there’s like 6+ meals to choose from.
• They have the same meals very frequently so it gets difficult to find options you haven’t tried

Comparison:

After writing this post, I got a lot of questions about meals that are already made (cooked) or servings for one. I tried a service called The Good Kitchen – they do fully prepared farm to table meals. They’re fresh meals, but you can put them in the freezer when you get them to extend the shelf life. I’ve gotten these meals several times now, and they’re super good!! The meals were really delicious, albeit a little pricey. I emailed them and they’re offering SweetPhi readers 15% off on their first order using code PHI15.

Also, after writing this post and reading the comments, Sun Basket is really loved by a lot of people. It’s all organic and the meals look super tasty-I have it on my calendar to try next month. Use this link to get $35 off Sun Basket meals!

Summary:

If you’re interested in home meal delivery services, the right one is out there for you!

I was pleasantly surprised that each and every one of the services I tried offered a ‘first time customer’ discount of some kind. I do need to mention -this post is not sponsored by any of the companies I mentioned in any way. I paid for all the services  myself (some have referral programs where if you order using my code or special link, you’ll get a discount and I’ll get some kind of credit for future orders or a small amount from your first order.) All opinions are mine alone and based on my experience.

Funny thing is, without even looking at the graph, my favorite service was Home Chef and a close second was Plated (they have dessert options)! Both had seemingly the best options and the least amount of dishes! For healthy, organic and very dietary needs accommodating (if you’re gluten-free/etc.) my favorite was Sun Basket, a service I tried after putting together the chart, I get them frequently now because we’re always trying to eat a little healthier.

Have you ever tried home meal delivery services? What did you think?